Making CBT for Insomnia Stick: A Guide for New Clinicians
Updated: 2 days ago
Nine things to consider when getting started with CBT-I
The plan is the easy part
At first glance, delivering CBT for Insomnia (CBT-I) can seem quite simple. The basic CBT-I protocol can be learnt in a few days of training, so you can be forgiven for confidently striding into your first few sleep sessions, convinced that a grateful and well-slept patient will soon be returning to thank you.
While this can certainly happen, especially when a patient is highly motivated and has lower levels of anxiety, often what decides whether CBT-I is successful is everything around the actual advice given. Things like how the plan is explained, whether the patient believes in it, and what you do when week two goes sideways.
The challenging truth is that we can share techniques which are proven to be effective in research, but unless a person implements them, they are of minimal benefit.
Getting off to a good start can make a considerable difference to how patients engage with CBT-I. This guide shares nine things I think about when introducing treatment, to help patients understand what we’re asking them to do, why it matters and how to make a start. Most are small shifts that take minimal to no extra time in the room, only a different way of communicating. In my 15 years of delivering CBT for Insomnia within public healthcare, where motivation is not always high, I have found they improve the chances of patients engaging early and, ultimately, achieving a good outcome.
The nine at a glance
1 | Build the relationship before you build the plan |
2 | Normalise and explain |
3 | Give the mechanism, not just the guidance |
4 | Set honest expectations |
5 | Troubleshoot concerns |
6 | Involve the people around them |
7 | Check confidence, not just agreement |
8 | Keep the plan simple enough to repeat back |
9 | Follow up early |
Want to keep this?
Download the full guide to Making CBT-I Stick, written for clinicians delivering insomnia treatment. It is free to download, print and share.
1 Build the relationship before you build the plan
Across psychological therapies, the therapeutic alliance, including trust, emotional bond, and agreement on goals and tasks, is consistently associated with better treatment outcomes (Flückiger et al., 2018). In the insomnia clinic, patients often arrive exhausted and with low self-efficacy, only too aware of the many unsuccessful attempts they have already made to fix their sleep and fearful that yet again, their problem will be dismissed or belittled. With this backdrop, making sure the patient feels properly listened to is part of the treatment, not the warm-up act. As I repeatedly say to students, “no-one cares what you know until they know that you care”.
In practice, this means listening carefully to understand not just what is happening, but how it makes them feel. It means using the patient’s own words rather than translating them into yours, acknowledging the distress that insomnia causes and the scepticism that comes of years of seemingly trying ‘everything’ and never finding a solution.
It also means collaborating with them to create a plan that they buy into. Our aim isn’t to get patients to comply with instructions, but to help them understand, agree with and feel motivated to engage in changes that are appropriate for them.
WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE
|
2 Normalise and explain
When we understand why we’re experiencing something, it can feel less threatening and more manageable. Helping patients make sense of what is happening with their sleep, their thoughts and their body’s responses can reduce frustration and take some of the stress out of insomnia, which gives the nervous system a chance to settle.
The aim is to make the problem make sense before asking anyone to change anything.
WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE
|
3 Give the mechanism, not just the guidance
An instruction alone, without an explanation of why it works, can result in short-lived engagement, particularly when the advice feels counter-intuitive or difficult. Helping patients understand the mechanism behind the intervention gives them a reason to persevere when things get challenging.
WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE
|
A picture or metaphor like that of the fuel tank can make the theory more relatable and memorable, especially at 3am.
4 Set honest expectations
Tell patients early that improvement takes practice and that the first weeks may feel harder before they feel better. Without this, they may panic that the advice isn’t working, or that it will never get any easier, and give up. Especially with behavioural approaches like sleep scheduling or stimulus control, progress is a bit like cycling uphill. The first few weeks are hard work, so much so that you spend the whole time wondering whether the effort is worth it, or whether you should just get off and walk. The effort feels far greater than the progress. Once you pass the brow of the hill, momentum builds and the next few weeks feel more like the downhill stretch. There may still be a bump in the road later, which is normal, and the skills you now have will help you get back on track.

A The first few weeks: uphill Hard work, and the effort feels far greater than the progress. | B The brow of the hill Momentum starts to build. |
C The next few weeks: downhill Things feel easier. | D A bump later on: normal The skills you now have help you get back on track. |
WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE
|
5 Troubleshoot concerns
Even when someone agrees to make a change, they may have doubts or insights into what might get in the way that they only volunteer when asked.
Ask about likely barriers early on, while motivation is at its highest: lack of time, forgetting, doubt about the method, an unsupportive partner. This gives you vital information about what this patient needs most or finds hardest. Validate their concerns, then work with them to troubleshoot.
WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE
|
If a patient says they have tried something before and it “didn’t work”, tune into the word work. Referring to a technique as either working or not working is very black and white and holds it to a much higher standard than we apply to most new things in life. I’ve never heard anyone say that getting fit, or their first piano lesson, didn’t work. That binary assumption discourages further attempts. Ask what working would have looked like, then steer towards a willingness to try again and see whether the outcome is different this time, with a plan built around them and support alongside it.
Remember that the best treatment plan is one that is tailored to the individual sitting in front of you. Consider their health, daily routines, responsibilities and circumstances when agreeing what is realistic.
6 Involve the people around them
Sleep doesn’t happen in isolation. The support, or lack of it, from a partner or close family member can have a real effect on whether someone sticks with CBT-I (Kamen et al., 2019).
It is often helpful for patients to share their plan with the people they live with before they start, including what has been recommended and what support might help. That might mean a partner offering a reminder or adjusting their own routine, or others in the household keeping noise down at a certain time.
Sometimes patients may be concerned about disturbing a partner when getting up in the night or a partner may be generally unhappy about changes to the bedtime routine. In that situation, I encourage the patient to talk to their partner and help them prepare by exploring what it would mean for them both if treatment worked.
WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE
Patients often mention more energy, feeling calmer and being less irritable, which lets you follow with:
|
7 Check confidence, not just agreement
A patient who nods and says “okay” has told you they heard the plan, but this nod of agreement frequently masks the doubts and concerns that mean they walk away and do nothing differently.
Before the session ends, ask for a rating of confidence. A lower figure is not a problem. It may be the most useful disclosure of the session, because it shows you where to adjust the plan before the patient struggles. Generally, a score of six or below suggests the agreed action may be too challenging and needs reconsidering. Explore what would make it more achievable, maybe breaking it down into smaller steps, making it less demanding or agreeing an easier starting point.
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
Six or below - reconsider the plan | Seven or above - go ahead | |||||||||
WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE
|
8 Keep the plan simple enough for the patient to repeat it back
A plan the patient can hold in their head is a plan they can do. That said, most people benefit from written or visual handouts. Before they leave, ask them to explain what they have understood from the session or what their next intended steps are. The gaps in their version show you exactly where to go next.
WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE
|
9 Follow up early
The first few weeks are where most plans are either built or abandoned. Early change in insomnia severity can be a predictor of short-term response (Hu et al., 2026). A brief early check-in therefore gives you an opportunity to normalise early difficulties, troubleshoot practical barriers and adapt the plan before the patient concludes that treatment is not working.
Explain how a patient can access support if needed before their next appointment. This could be sharing your email or inviting them to a drop-in clinic if resources allow.
If you work within public healthcare, such as the NHS where I work, you may not have capacity to provide additional support between appointments. You could signpost patients to other sources of help in the meantime. The free CBT-i Coach app is designed to be used alongside therapist-led CBT-I and can help patients monitor their sleep and work through treatment strategies between sessions. The Sleep Charity’s free National Sleep Helpline offers a different kind of support, providing general advice and guidance around sleep. Neither replaces individual clinical follow-up, but both may offer useful additional support.
When it doesn’t hold. What non-adherence can tell us
Despite our best efforts, patients won’t always implement the changes we’ve agreed. When this happens, before assuming the patient isn’t motivated or ready, it’s worth considering what we might have overlooked.
What patients say | What I may have missed | What I could do differently |
“I don’t think this will work” | The rationale wasn’t sufficiently convincing or previous disappointments haven’t been addressed. | Revisit the rationale and explore what would make this approach feel different. |
“It’s too hard” | The ask was too big, too soon, for what the patient could manage. | Break it down or adapt the plan. |
“I forgot” | The plan lacked a practical reminder or routine. | Agree a prompt or link the action to an existing habit. |
“I’ve tried this before” | The previous attempt, and why this one might be different, wasn’t explored. | Explore previous experiences and identify what needs to change. |
“I didn’t have time” | The patient’s daily commitments and routines weren’t taken into account. | Revisit the practicalities and agree something realistic. |
“My partner isn’t happy about it” | The effect of the changes on the partner, and their concerns, weren’t considered. | Explore the partner’s concerns and, where appropriate, involve them in understanding the rationale and agreeing practical changes. |
“I felt worse” | The patient wasn’t prepared for what to expect, and how tolerable it felt wasn’t reviewed. | Explore what felt worse, revisit expectations and review whether the intervention needs adapting. |
Adapted from the perspective described by Devine, Edwards and Feldman (2018), who challenge clinicians to look beyond the patient when considering barriers to treatment adherence.
TAKE HOMEE HOMECBT-I can be a transformative approach, and seeing people’s sleep and lives change as a result makes delivering it a privileged and rewarding place to work. While the principles may be simple, that simplicity can blindside us to the importance of how we deliver them. CBT for Insomnia training has also traditionally given less attention to this, focusing more on theory than on the reality of practice. In many cases, better outcomes don’t come from more sessions or working harder. They come from making the time we have count: a clear explanation, a realistic plan and a patient who feels heard. When treatment doesn’t hold, the most useful question is rarely “what’s wrong with this patient?” but “what could I do differently?” The answer is often small, and it is usually within reach. |
Further resourcesFor resources for healthcare practitioners or resources for people with sleep difficulties check out my resources page. I’m adding to them regularly. |
References
Devine, F., Edwards, T., & Feldman, S. R. (2018). Barriers to treatment: Describing them from a different perspective. Patient Preference and Adherence, 12, 129–133. https://doi.org/10.2147/PPA.S147420
Flückiger, C., Del Re, A. C., Wampold, B. E., & Horvath, A. O. (2018). The alliance in adult psychotherapy: A meta-analytic synthesis. Psychotherapy, 55(4), 316–340. https://doi.org/10.1037/pst0000172
Hu, Y., Ni, Z., Wang, S., Zheng, S., Weng, N., Lai, P., Huang, S., & Wei, X. (2026). The prognostic value of early treatment factors for cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia (CBT-I) outcomes. Nature and Science of Sleep, 18, 599377. https://doi.org/10.2147/NSS.S599377
Kamen, C., Garland, S. N., Heckler, C. E., Peoples, A. R., Kleckner, I. R., Cole, C. L., Perlis, M. L., Morrow, G. R., Mustian, K. M., & Roscoe, J. A. (2019). Social support, insomnia, and adherence to cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia after cancer treatment. Behavioral Sleep Medicine, 17(1), 70–80. https://doi.org/10.1080/15402002.2016.1276019
About the author
I’m Louise Berger, an Occupational Therapist and behavioural sleep medicine specialist. I founded the NHS Insomnia Clinic at Royal Surrey County Hospital in 2012 and have spent 15 years delivering CBT for Insomnia within the NHS, where motivation isn’t always high and time is short. I’m passionate about improving access to sleep and insomnia care through training, clinical tools, advisory support, national standards and private therapy.

Comments